News

Do You Really Want a Promotion? Choosing Your Own Career Path in Higher Education

HigherEdMilitary

Blueastro/Shutterstock
October 12, 2026

Most of us have encountered that master of the craft who seems to always know the answer or who can solve just about any problem. This person's organizational reputation is competence. This person holds little interest in moving up the career ladder, intent to lead as an individual contributor modeling an example of excellence, enhancing the mission, and transforming the organization. There is no doubt that this "lone wolf" who holds in-depth professional knowledge is valuable. Yet, some organizational cultures discourage alignment with this mindset, labeling these individuals as non-team players. The successful individual contributor may even be pressured to assume a different role or new title but is then directly or indirectly marginalized for turning down advancement. Not seeking promotion, more pay, or a bigger title may be perceived as a violation of sacrosanct organizational norms. Navigation of the higher education promotion environment was addressed in the article VUCA, Veterans, and Moving Up the Ranks in Higher Education. That theme is continued here, arguing that career advancement and promotion need not be everyone's goal, and professional fulfillment takes different forms.

Those who question the desirability of advancement may be viewed as putting self-interest ahead of organizational needs. Equating career advancement with organizational commitment, however, overlooks important distinctions. There is more than one way to lead, contribute, and build a meaningful professional life. Some of the widespread employee quiet-quitting regularly addressed in the organizational literature may center on those who reject career ladder ambition because their job satisfaction and, moreover, life contentment, reside in professional mastery of their craft. If this idea resonates, there is reason for optimism. As the business executive Graham Weaver advised, "The truest form of intelligence is designing the life you want to live."

For many people, there is a time and a place for career advancement at some point in life. When life and career align, and advancement is sensible and desired, seize the opportunity. But the pressure of the work hard-compete-succeed-get promoted cycle is not for everyone, or perhaps the timing may not be right. Here are some questions higher ed professionals may wrestle with, which should be deeply reflected upon:

  • Do I actually want a promotion?
  • Is it okay to be happy with my current employment situation rather than seek advancement?
  • Am I disappointing others or failing to live up to my potential simply because I do not want to become a leader or assume greater responsibility?
  • Is the additional stress that often accompanies advancement worth it?

Higher education professionals must first define success on their own terms to answer these questions. In the book, "10x is Easier than 2x: How World-Class Entrepreneurs Achieve More by Doing Less," the authors Dan Sullivan and Dr. Benjamin Hardy discuss mastering one's unique ability. Everyone has a unique ability, which they describe as "the purest and freest expression of our self and our purpose," in which "no one else can compete with you even if they wanted to." It is the area in which "you have superior skills, where you're completely intrinsically motivated and thus energized and engaged, and it's also where you see never-ending possibility for improvement." Most importantly, your "Unique ability requires you to determine what you personally like and dislike doing, and decide that others' opinions about it are irrelevant." For higher education professionals, harnessing one's unique ability may involve advancing up the career ladder, or it could mean excelling as an individual contributor in your department or office. It may take the form of leading others, or it could be found by mastering one's craft. Again, you must define success for yourself.

In conclusion, there can be a professional or reputational price to pay for going against the grain of organizational culture and expectations, but the long-term reward of individual authenticity and autonomy is worth it. After all, why pursue a career that regularly leaves you needing to take a vacation to escape it? If the organizational culture or intensity is a mismatch, be ready to vote with your feet, in a kind manner, of course. Advancement and promotions do not guarantee happiness for all people, but if you define success through promotion, then pursue that path. Taking into consideration the various points above, if you realize that success for you does not equate to advancement because of the strings attached, then do more reflecting to advance a strategy that secures victory for your life. If you have found your calling, assess whether promoting into higher roles within that niche seems to be a natural evolution for your career. The idea that promotion equates to success only works if the individual personally defines it that way. Live intentionally rather than defaulting to the expectations of others. Leaders within post-secondary education institutions would do well to keep these considerations in mind when supporting their multi-faceted employee workforce.

Disclaimer: HigherEdMilitary encourages free discourse and expression of issues while striving for accurate presentation to our audience. A guest opinion serves as an avenue to address and explore important topics, for authors to impart their expertise to our higher education audience and to challenge readers to consider points of view that could be outside of their comfort zone. The viewpoints, beliefs, or opinions expressed in the above piece are those of the author(s) and don't imply endorsement by HigherEdMilitary.

Article Topics

Republish this article for free. We want to make it easier for you to share knowledge and creativity, and encourage you to reuse our articles under a Creative Commons license.
Feedback

Feedback

If you have suggestions for how we can improve HigherEdMilitary or topics we should cover, let us know.

HigherEdMilitary is part of the HigherEdJobs network.